Haiti Recovery

—

2–3 minutes

International Relations

If I could use only one word to describe this legislation today, it’s optimistic. Rest assured, I condemn the fact that the author of this bill and the affirmation are attempting to reach over international borders to help those suffering under Haiti’s current humanitarian crisis. But, we must be honest:  this bill is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It promises instant progress in a nation facing decades of instability. That isn’t realistic. It’s wishful thinking at best. Therefore, senators do not affirm this legislation.

First, do not pass today’s legislation for the victims stranded amidst Haiti’s humanitarian crisis. This legislation creates the illusion that the crisis will fix itself simply by pouring money into a police force already tied to abuse and instability. Instead of resolving the conflict, by passing, we add more fuel to the fire, strengthening the very system responsible for the suffering of thousands of innocent civilians. In fact, The Human Rights Watch in collaboration with the UN Integrated Office in Haiti tells us that the Haitian National Police Force is responsible for the deaths of more than 407 individuals as of September of 2023, executing at least 18 people in uniform in Tabaree, an urban Commune just northeast of the main part of Port-Au-Prince, the capital of Haiti. Additionally, the police internal affairs office opened cases of alleged human rights violations against 103 officers from January through September. These mass executions highlight that the police force we are funding has already turned its weapons on the very people it’s meant to protect, therefore, supplying them with even more resources risks harming Haitian civilians instead of protecting them. And while this legislation and the affirmation may claim it will “monitor how the money is being used”, it never actually tells us how, leaving loads of fuzzy grey areas where aid can slip through the cracks and end up in the wrong hands.

Second, you fail for the long term displacement of our U.S. troops.  This legislation sends our troops into a situation so unstable and long-lasting such that they could remain there for years, stuck in a mission that was unrealistic and never designed to bring real, lasting change from the start. Historical evidence shows that even “limited” U.S. missions in Haiti have turned into long-term deployments. According to the Congressional Research Service, after the 1994 intervention officially ended, hundreds of U.S. troops were still left in Haiti for years, staying on the ground to handle reconstruction and security tasks because the situation remained unstable. This kind of deployment doesn’t just physically and mentally drain our troops but it keeps them away from their families and puts them in danger without a clear return date. And because this bill repeats the same vague strategy we’ve tried before, with no solid plan for how the money will be “monitored” or success measured, I’m not willing to risk our troops’ safety on another mission that could leave them stuck while the crisis still goes unsolved.

Per my previous statements, you fail today’s legislation for the Haitian people and our U.S. troops.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *