Education
Across the United States, an alarming number of books have been banned for including “controversial topics.” In the 2023-2024 school year, over 10,000 books were banned from public schools according to PEN America. Many of these books contained topics related to race, history, and science. By preventing the ban on controversial topics, we protect the First Amendment and preserve the integrity of education. Senators, I stand before you today in support of preventing the ban on controversial topics in schools. If we continue to ban controversial topics, we will deprive our students of knowledge.
First, preventing the ban protects the First Amendment. The First Amendment was ratified in 1791 and granted the freedoms of speech, press, religion, and assembly. Banning certain subjects in school violates this exact amendment. According to U.S. Courts, school administrations can only restrict speech that is harmful to other students, for example, the promotion of drug use. Any other topic such as the history of racism is not harmful to students, and in fact, it is an integral piece of our history. Limiting access to specific subjects is a form of government censorship according to the American Library Association. This kind of censorship goes against the core principle of free expression as stated in the First Amendment. The amendment was created as a shield for our fundamental freedoms, ensuring that individuals could express their opinions and access information without any government interference. This is important because violating the First Amendment not only limits students’ access to knowledge and free expression but also erodes the foundations of individual freedom.
Second, preventing the ban preserves the integrity of education. This means maintaining the core values that make education effective and inclusive. This ensures that our education system remains honest and open to diverse perspectives. While this should be the case, it is not. According to a study published by NYU in 2024, in the last three years, over 80% of educators and parents that were surveyed, stated that there have been efforts to prohibit topics regarding sexual orientation and racism. That is just two out of eight subjects that have been censored at schools. Both subjects have been an integral part of our society, and are not harmful to students at all. These topics are very important in high school, especially because at this age, many students can relate and want to reach out about their opinions. Students can also learn about critical thinking by analyzing different viewpoints. According to a study by the Journal of Educational Psychology, students who are exposed to controversial topics are forced to critically evaluate evidence and develop stronger arguments. By learning about controversial topics, students are challenged to go beyond superficial understanding. This is important because it ensures that the education students are receiving remains honest, fair, and diverse.
Senators, supporting this resolution is the right thing to do. By preventing the ban on controversial topics, we can protect the First Amendment and preserve academic integrity. Students have the right to learn.
Leave a Reply